The Institute for Law Enforcement Administration
A Division of The Center for American and International Law
ILEA HomeAbout ILEAAdvisory BoardMembersPublicationsEthics CenterILEA Staff
Ethical Courage Award
Officer Keith Batt

2007 Ethics Achievement Award

Sergeant Bob Decker
Houston, TX, Police Department

A member of the Houston, TX, Police Department for more than two decades, Sergeant Bob Decker is the kind of law enforcement professional who inspires and uplifts everyone around him. While on a trip in Mexico Bob got lost - literally - in the colonias. At the same time, though, he says he was found. Since 2002 - on his own time - he has worked tirelessly in support of multiple orphanages and others in need in Mexico. He is, in fact, the founder of Paper Houses Across the Border, Inc., a non-profit group dedicated to the proposition that poverty and misery know no international boundaries. A description of the good works being performed by Bob Decker and his organization may be found at http://www.paperhouses.org

In recognition of his caring and altruistic efforts to ease the burdens of other human beings, on March 27, 2007, Houston Police Sergeant Bob Decker was presented with the 2007 Ethics Achievement Award. Sergeant Decker accepted his award at a special ceremony held during the annual Contemporary Issues and Ethics Conference at the headquarters of the Center for American and International Law in Plano, Texas.

________________________________________________________

Officer Keith Batt

2004 NOBLE SERVICE AWARD

Brownsville, TX, Police Department

When a routine shoplifting call led Brownsville, TX, police to a destitute family during the Christmas season of 2000, officers immediately raised – from other officers working that day on that patrol shift – sufficient money to provide immediate shelter, food and clothing. As one Brownsville officer put it: “God put us there at that moment, and we were their angels.” Once the immediate needs of the family were attended to, officers also made arrangements for long term assistance through various other public service entitites.

On October 22, 2004, at the 13th Annual International Ethics Conference, and in recognition of their demonstration of noble, compassionate policing, the Brownsville, TX, Police Department was presented with a Noble Service Award. Accepting the award on behalf of the Brownsville Police Department were Detective Joe Barrios and Officer Ted Torres.



Officer Keith Batt

2003 Ethics Achievement Award

Presented to Arizona Peace Officer Standards and Training

In early 2000, Arizona Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST) adopted a “zero tolerance” policy on certifying peace officers who had lied, a stance that became known, informally, as the POST “Integrity Wave.” Among agencies charged with oversight or certification of peace officers, Arizona POST has distinguished itself through its forward-looking emphasis on character and ethics as integral to the law enforcement profession.

On October 16, 2003, at the 12th Annual International Ethics Conference, and in recognition of their work in spotlighting the critical nature of ethics and integrity in law enforcement, Arizona Peace Officer Standards and Training was presented the Ethics Achievement Award. Accepting the award on behalf of Arizona POST was Mr. Thomas J. Hammarstrom, Executive Director of Arizona POST.


 
Officer Keith Batt

2002 ETHICAL COURAGE AWARD WINNER
Officer David Gebhardt
Rochester, New York, Police Department

On January 4, 2001, Officer David Gebhardt was the “point” person with the Rochester, New York, Police Narcotics Team, as they entered a home to execute a drug search warrant. He was the first officer through the door, but in moving toward a rear room, he tripped on electrical cords causing his shotgun to discharge, strike and mortally wound a 21-year old, unarmed man sitting in a chair. After this tragic incident, and prior to the case being presented to the Grand Jury or completion of the Internal Affairs investigation, Gebhardt issued a public statement. In it, he expressed his deep sense of sorrow, and accepted full responsibility for this accidental shooting. His public statement, which helped reduce tensions in the city, was applauded by the mayor and a number of other community leaders. David Gebhardt came face-to-face with one of the true “nightmares” in a police career. But according to Rochester Police Chief Robert Duffy, “his integrity, his character and his sense of responsibility to the profession and to his family not only helped him endure the trauma attached to these types of incidents, but in the end, he earned a whole new level of respect as a person, set a new standard for integrity and accountability on behalf of police officers, and served as an outstanding example for everyone in law enforcement.”

On October 18, 2002, at the 11th Annual International Ethics Conference, David Gebhardt accepted the Ethical Courage Award in recognition of his willingness to stand up for “the right thing,” and for his unhesitating demonstration of character and integrity.


Officer Keith Batt

2001 ETHICAL COURAGE AWARD WINNER
Officer Keith Batt
Pleasanton Police Department, CA

Born in San Francisco, Keith Batt grew up in Sebastopol, CA, before going on to Sacramento State University where he earned a Bachelor's Degree in Criminal Justice Administration. Upon graduation, he decided to pursue the life-long dream of becoming a police officer. Keith joined the Oakland, CA, Police Department, and in November, 1999, graduated number one academically from his Recruit Training class. When he was assigned to Field Training, his vision of law enforcement was badly shaken as he witnessed officers (including his FTO) engaging in brutality, falsifying reports and planting evidence. In his words, Batt said, "They took everything I valued about policing, everything I had looked forward to, and ruined it."

Deciding to take a stand against what he saw, Batt (a rookie officer on probation!) reported his observations and experiences to the Oakland PD Internal Affairs. His allegations (later corroborated by citizens) resulted in a supervisor being demoted, and the filing of thirty five felony and multiple misdemeanor counts against four Oakland Police officers. Considerable media attention was given to the legal process involving four rogue cops (known locally as "The Riders"), but through it all one fact is indisputable ... without Keith Batt's courageous stand there would have been no investigation and no criminal case.

Though he was encouraged to remain, Batt resigned from the Oakland Police Department. He was hired by the Pleasanton, CA, PD, where Chief Timothy Neal says "My agency is better for having Keith Batt employed as a police officer ... all of us in law enforcement stand a little taller because of Keith Batt."

On October 12, 2001, at the 10th Annual International Ethics Conference, Keith Batt received the Ethical Courage Award in recognition of his willingness to stand up for "the right thing," and for his unhesitating demonstration of character and integrity.


Perry Dunlop

2000 ETHICAL COURAGE AWARD WINNER
Mr. Perry Dunlop
British Columbia, Canada

Over the course of a distinguished law enforcement career which began in 1983, Constable Perry Dunlop worked in patrol, criminal investigations and the drug unit for the Cornwall, Ontario, Police Service. In recognition of his professionalism and courage, he was on two occasions chosen Cornwall Police Officer of the Year, once in 1987, and again in 1991.

In 1994, though, Constable Dunlop found himself in a very unfamiliar position, when he was charged with illegally revealing police information to a source outside his agency. Specifically, after learning of a case of reported child sexual abuse in which the alleged abuser was permitted to pay the victim a sum of money in lieu of criminal charges, Dunlop asked why his agency was not investigating the case or reporting the matter - as required - to the appropriate child protective authorities. Despite being cautioned to stay away from the case, Dunlop reported it to the Children's Aid Society; an act which resulted in disciplinary charges from his department. He was twice cleared of any wrongdoing, and a special task force eventually was formed to investigate allegations of widespread child sexual abuse.

Because of his outspoken stand against official silence and inertia, Perry Dunlop and his family were harassed and ostracized both in the community and within his police agency. In July, 2000, Perry Dunlop resigned from the Cornwall Police Service and moved with his wife and three children to western Canada.

On October 13, 2000, at the 9th Annual International Ethics Conference, Perry Dunlop received the Ethical Courage Award in recognition of his willingness to stand up for "the right thing," and for his unhesitating demonstration of character and integrity.


1999 ETHICAL COURAGE AWARD WINNER

David Snyder

Mr. David Snyder
Amarillo, Texas

In November, 1994, David Snyder, former Chief of Police at Texas State Technical Institute in Amarillo, Texas, got the bad news ... he was being terminated for insubordination. He had trouble believing it, for after an unblemished career (six as chief), he was being fired for failing to obey an order from his boss. But even in the midst of that difficult time, he knew he had done the right thing, for the "order" had been a directive for him to stop investigating a series of criminal matters on his campus, and to turn over all his records.

After his dismissal, Chief Snyder was forced to sell his house, seek other employment, and move his family to a new community. Eventually he sued his former employer under the state of Texas Whistleblower Act, and in February, 1998, he prevailed in his suit. He was awarded a monetary settlement, though that did not signal the end of his difficulty. Despite his desire to remain active in the field of law enforcement, the stress from his ordeal has caused physical problems that make it impossible to do so. He is now employed in the private sector.

On October 29, 1999, at the 8th Annual Ethics Conference, David Snyder received the Ethical Courage Award in recognition of his willingness stand up for "the right thing," and his unhesitating demonstration of character and integrity.


1998 ETHICAL COURAGE AWARD WINNER

Jeffrey Harbin

Chief Jeffrey Harbin
Carnegie Police Department, PA

On December 26, 1997, a 25 mile-long high-speed pursuit ended in the small community of Carnegie, PA, a suburb of Pittsburgh. As a Carnegie Police Officer was taking the driver into custody, several members of another agency swarmed the driver, and appeared to use excessive force in restraining him. The event was captured on the Carnegie P.D. in-car camera. The circumstances and the video were brought to the attention of Police Chief Jeffrey Harbin who immediately turned the tape over to the County Prosecutor.

After the video was enhanced, a Grand Jury decided there was insufficient evidence to indict for assault, but recommended that two of the officers seen on tape be prosecuted for lying in their reports about the arrest. Once that report was made public, Chief Harbin and the members of the Carnegie Police were subjected to a barrage of harassment from a small-but-vocal number of other police officers in the Pittsburgh area, including some who publicly proclaimed "You never turn in another cop." Over time, harassment escalated to the point where other officers on the area radio network keyed their microphones to prevent Carnegie officers from transmitting or receiving messages; direct threats to the safety of officers and citizens in Carnegie.

In stepping forward immediately to report the apparent use of excessive force in the arrest made in his city, Chief Jeffrey Harbin demonstrated unimpeachable strength of character and moral courage. On October 30, 1998, at the 7th Annual Ethics Conference, Jeffrey Harbin accepted the inaugural Ethical Courage Award.

 
Ethics Center Home

Return to The Center for Law Enforcement Ethics

Ethics Advisory Council

Established to assist in charting the future of the Ethics Center. Read about the members here.

Ethical Courage Award Past Winners

Click on the recipient's name name to access their story:

Arizona Peace Officer Standards and Training
(2003)

Off. David Gebhardt
(2002)

Off. Keith Batt
(2001)

Mr. Perry Dunlop
(2000)

Mr. David Snyder (1999)

Chief Jeffrey Harbin (1998)

CAIL Home

Return to The Center for American and International Law.

Join ILEA

Click here to become a member of the Institute for Law Enforcement Administration.

Please note: the application requires Acrobat Reader in order to view. To download your free copy, click here.

ILEA Calendar
Click here to view ILEA's Program Calendar.
   
 

Institute for Law Enforcement Administration
5201 Democracy Drive | Plano, Texas 75024-3561 | 972.244.3430 | 972.244.3431 (fax)
ilea@cailaw.org

 
click here for full CLE Calendar Symposium on Private Investments Abroad International Antitrust Law Academy of American and International Law ICLC Calendar International Antitrust Law Academy of American and International Law Symposium on Private Abroad Programs History and Goals